Why Newcastle could benefit from a formation tweak against in-form Man City

After a 5,000-mile Champions League round trip to Azerbaijan to face Qarabag, it’s unlikely that Eddie Howe and his Newcastle United side would have handpicked a Premier League showdown with Manchester City at the Etihad Stadium as their next assignment.
City, who recently overcame Newcastle over two legs in the Carabao Cup, know that victory here would heap pressure on Arsenal. Three points would move them to within two of the Gunners, who are not in action until Sunday’s North London derby — a significant psychological edge at this stage of the campaign.
Vital points at stake
Pep Guardiola’s side are unbeaten in their last four league outings, while Newcastle’s 2-1 win over Tottenham Hotspur ended a frustrating four-match winless run.
The Magpies’ numbers tell their own story. Scoring and conceding 37 goals in 26 Premier League matches during the 2025/26 season makes for compelling viewing, but it underlines a lack of balance that has at times undermined their European ambitions. They currently sit eight points adrift of Chelsea in the race for a top-five finish.
Newcastle will draw confidence from November’s victory over City at St James’ Park, a result that offered a blueprint for unsettling a side renowned for surging through the final months of a title race.
A daunting Etihad record
However, history is firmly against them. City have won 10, drawn two and lost just one of their home league fixtures this season. Newcastle, by contrast, have taken only 13 points from a possible 39 away from home and have managed just one win in their last five league matches.
More ominously, City are unbeaten in their last 21 Premier League home games against Newcastle, winning the last 16 in succession — the second-longest such streak in English top-flight history. In 20 Premier League visits to the Etihad, Newcastle have never won.
Woltemade and Haaland headline threats
Should Newcastle spring a surprise, they would complete their first league double over City since 1983/84 — and their first top-flight double since 1955/56.
Harvey Barnes struck twice in November’s win, but no Newcastle player has scored home and away against City in the same campaign since Alan Shearer in 2004/05.
A key weapon for the visitors could be 6ft 6in forward Nick Woltemade. Newcastle’s eight headed goals rank among the highest in the division, and no side has delivered more open-play crosses into the box this season. Woltemade’s aerial presence — allied with his seven league goals — provides a clear pattern to Newcastle’s attacking play.
For City, much will depend on Erling Haaland. With 22 league goals — 11 of them opening strikes — he remains the division’s most decisive scorer. However, he faces a late fitness test, as do Savinho and Max Alleyne. Guardiola is definitely without Jeremy Doku, Josko Gvardiol and Mateo Kovacic.
Gordon in the groove
Newcastle also have injury concerns of their own. Bruno Guimarães, who has nine goals this season, is among those ruled out. Emil Krafth, Fabian Schär and Tino Livramento are confirmed absentees, while Yoane Wissa, Sven Botman and Lewis Miley face late fitness checks.
That places added emphasis on Anthony Gordon, fresh from a stunning four-goal midweek display that etched his name into the record books.
Late drama likely?
Interestingly, Newcastle have yet to concede in the opening 15 minutes of a league match this season. Yet they have shipped 14 goals in the final quarter-hour — the worst record in the division during that period.
City’s goals are more evenly distributed across matches, and given Newcastle’s exhausting European travels, the latter stages could prove decisive as fatigue sets in.
A case for tactical restraint?
For Howe, pragmatism may be the key. Persisting with his customary 4-3-3 against a City side desperate for points could play directly into Guardiola’s hands. A more compact, defensively structured system — perhaps introducing an additional centre-back or a deeper midfield screen — might offer the visitors their best hope of emerging with something tangible.
With just 11 league games remaining after this fixture, Newcastle’s margin for error in the chase for European qualification is slim. A point at the Etihad would represent not just a statistical anomaly, but potentially a pivotal moment in their season.
Share this content:








