Manchester United’s minimal activity in the January transfer window came as little surprise. Beyond the financial considerations, it’s clear the club first needs clarity on who will be in the dugout next season before making decisions about the squad.

The lesson from past managerial changes is evident. When Erik ten Hag was allowed to make signings before leaving, successors inherited players they might not have wanted. With Michael Carrick now in a second caretaker spell, the club has understandably exercised caution in any major investment until the permanent managerial appointment is confirmed.

Carrick’s early performances have put him in contention for the permanent role, but prudence remains key. As transfer expert Dean Jones notes, United must also be aware of the summer market and potential transfer conditions.

Midfield reinforcements a priority

One position long flagged for improvement is central midfield. Bruno Fernandes remains vital, but at 32, the possibility of a lucrative move—potentially to Saudi Arabia—cannot be ignored. United also lack a defensive-minded midfielder who can drive forward the way legends like Bryan Robson or Roy Keane did.

Manuel Ugarte has struggled to meet expectations, and young prospect Kobbie Mainoo, while talented, is more naturally attacking. This context fuels speculation around Brighton’s Carlos Baleba and Nottingham Forest’s Elliot Anderson.

Comparing Anderson and Baleba

Both midfielders are young—Baleba 22, Anderson 23—and still developing, which makes either an appealing long-term prospect. While neither is a prolific goal scorer, Anderson’s three goals and eight assists in 72 games for Forest compare well to Baleba’s four goals and two assists in 99 games for Brighton. Anderson’s recent England call-up reflects his growing profile.

Anderson has been a key driver for Forest, completing 907 of 1,143 forward passes in the final third, making 175 separate 10+ progressive carries, winning 110 of 174 tackles, and regaining possession 466 times. His aerial ability is notable too, winning 103 of 169 headed duels.

Baleba offers a similarly combative style. Physically strong and composed under pressure, he has lost just 77 of 169 tackles, contested 802 duels with a success rate close to Anderson’s, and made 401 ball recoveries along with 181 10+ progressive carries. He has completed 2,660 of 2,997 passes, demonstrating his reliability in possession.

Decision will come down to finances and ambition

Both players excel in the defensive and transitional roles United need. Any summer move will likely hinge on finances, player preference, and the lure of Champions League football. If United can offer Europe’s elite competition, convincing Baleba or Anderson to stay at Brighton or Forest will be a tough challenge for the respective clubs.